From flaky pastry to rich fillings, the humble pie has long been a cornerstone of British cooking. Rank these five contenders by your personal preference and settle the debate at the dinner table.
Put the items in your preferred order.
Steak and Ale Pie
Slow-cooked beef braised in dark ale, encased in buttery shortcrust pastry. A proper plateful that pairs perfectly with mash and gravy.
Chicken and Mushroom Pie
Tender chicken and earthy mushrooms in a creamy white sauce, topped with golden puff pastry. A nostalgic favourite that never disappoints.
Cornish Pasty
Beef, swede, potato and onion wrapped in a crimped pastry parcel. Protected by PGI status and championed by the South West for good reason.
Pork Pie
Hot water crust pastry hugging seasoned pork and a layer of jellied stock. A Melton Mowbray icon best enjoyed cold with piccalilli.

Shepherd's Pie
Minced lamb simmered with vegetables and crowned with creamy mashed potato. The ultimate midweek comfort food on a cold British evening.
Drag the photo to reorder
Which 1968 Peter Sellers comedy features him playing an Indian actor named Hrundi V. Bakshi who accidentally destroys a Hollywood dinner party?
π₯ Movies & Series Β· 26 votes
Should England football fans be banned from booing opposition national anthems at Wembley?
β½ Sport Β· 25 votes
Should UK ministers be banned from appearing on reality TV shows while in office?
ποΈ Politics Β· 25 votes
Which British cheese deserves a permanent spot on the nation's cheeseboard?
π³ 27 votes